attenzione please


if ai gets a design 80% of the way there, what is the designer's job now?

note 005 · published · tags: , , ,

the last 20%. and most of that 20% is removing things. ai throws a bunch of stuff on the page and it looks good. the designer's job is to dive deeper and say, actually this isn't adding value, pull it out.

80/20

someone on our team had a call this week with a product designer at a big consultancy. their take: ai "can probably get 80 of the way there. but that last 20 of real craft is obviously what it struggles with." and that last 20% "is going to be the differentiator."

i agree. that 20% is what makes products stand out.

the new skill is critique

the thing is, a designer's skill set was figuring out how to build a page. now the page is already built. so you have to understand what to remove, what doesn't make sense.

that's not a natural designer instinct. critiquing a design that wasn't made by you, and cutting things out. you have to be really rigorous about what you agree should go into the product and what you pull out.

skip that and you get ai slop. lots of things on the screen, the idea sounds cool, but it's not functional and doesn't add value.

the prototype is the working document

their workflow: "we're just prototyping with claude code, barely ever touching figma." they iterate with the people asking for it and with users, tighten everything up, then do one big export to figma. "the prototype is almost like the working document." figma "just becomes the documentation layer."

so the job looks less like pushing pixels and more like "having really good conversations". getting to the bottom of problems, iterating solutions, testing things. they said the hard design skills people spent years building are "no longer important". on our side we still go in and tweak by hand sometimes, when we really want to get that last 20%.

teams get smaller

on one of their recent projects the team was four people, then only one got extended. that one person says they're doing the work of three, at sensible hours, with enough time to think.

so if you're a designer, get good at saying no to the stuff ai adds. that's the job now, no?

markdown: https://attenzioneplease.com/notes/what-is-the-designers-job-when-ai-gets-you-80-percent-there.md
short link: https://attenzioneplease.com/5
cite as: attenzione please, note 005, "if ai gets a design 80% of the way there, what is the designer's job now?", 2026-11-19, https://attenzioneplease.com/notes/what-is-the-designers-job-when-ai-gets-you-80-percent-there